Can Mobile Broadband Bite into Fixed Broadband?

Nielsen Mobile, a service of The Nielsen Company, reported that there were more than 13 million wireless data card users in the US as of Q2 2008. The interesting piece of information buried in the press release is that as many as 59 percent of the mobile data card users were willing to swap their current ISP for their broadband needs, indicating shaky loyalty and low switching costs for ISPs. This is not too surprising given that a USB dongle/modem/stick solution can address their mobile as well as fixed connectivity requirements.

The latest research from YouGov has revealed that one in every eight Mobile Broadband users have replaced their existing land-line ISP, using their wireless card instead of the land-line alternative. The UK regulator Ofcom which issues a very informative annual report on the state of the market for communication services in UK declared that there were more than 100k+ new mobile broadband connections per month in the UK in H1 2008, with the rate of sign-up accelerating. As many as 75% of dongle users are using their mobile connection at home. Mobile broadband subscriptions in countries like Austria and Sweden are growing at a rate much faster than that of fixed line broadband connections like DSL. Mobile broadband pricing from most of the UK operators are cheaper than the fixed line options (the mobile broadband plans have monthly download limits, though). Operators like 3 UK and T-Mobile UK are rumored to come out with 3G routers equipped with WiFi that could be positioned as broadband platforms for the home office – somewhat similar to Vodafone Station a switch/router that has a removable USB key (for 3G/HSPA service) as well as a ADSL2+ port that can be shared via Fixed Ethernet or Wi-Fi across the home (see figure). The USB key can be used for connectivity needs on-the-go and can be inserted into the Station for 3G mobile broadband while back at home. It is not clear how many people will actually use the ADSL2+ service.

The implication of all of this is clear: Mobile operators are leveraging the popularity of 3G USB dongles to bite into the market share of the fixed broadband market. According to the Nielsen Mobile report, data cards are becoming an increasingly popular choice for in-home, personal Internet access. While most of these mobile broadband plans come with monthly data allowance limits, how many broadband users would really exceed 5GB data usage in a month? Most broadband usage studies have reported that 5% of the user base generate upwards of 80% of data usage. If you leave out these heavy users, for the casual Internet user, the choice between $60 for tethered home Internet access or $60 for Internet that they can take with them becomes an interesting value proposition. In any case, cable operators in the US are beginning to limit the monthly data usage of their subscribers and it is likely that other fixed broadband operators will follow suit.

The upshot is that aggressive 3G mobile operators are positioned well in taking away some market share from fixed broadband operators. The implication of all this additional traffic load on the mobile network is a different matter, though. There is a note of caution for mobile operators in the YouGov research. Over 25% of existing mobile broadband subscribers were contemplating the cancellation of their contract, citing woeful performance (slow speeds) and high costs as being among their primary concerns. Marek Vaygelt, head of technology and telecommunications consulting at YouGov said, “Customers’ find Mobile Broadband easy to use and install but transmission speeds and to a lesser extent network coverage reduce the initial enjoyment of getting up and running.”


Filed under HSPA, mobile broadband

2 responses to “Can Mobile Broadband Bite into Fixed Broadband?

  1. Pingback: Interesting Chart on Mobile Broadband Pricing Premium (or Lack thereof) « Mobile Broadband Blog

  2. Pingback: 3G Routers - Will It Accelerate Fixed Broadband Replacement? « Mobile Broadband Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s